Comparing Costs: Generative AI or Conversational AI for ROI

Businesses used to ask, “Should we use AI?”
Now they’re asking, ‘Which type of AI delivers better ROI?’ In other words, they’re wondering if they should go with Generative AI or Conversational AI for ROI.

A good question.
Because not all AI is built for the same job.

Some AI writes blog posts. Others answer customer questions at 2 AM.

In fact, Lowe’s stores has introduced the “Mylow Companion,” an AI tool that combines Generative AI and Conversational AI to assist store associates. 

This tool enables employees to quickly access product information, inventory details, and home improvement advice through voice-to-text prompts on handheld devices, enhancing customer service across its 1,700+ stores.

So today, we’re figuring out which one fits your business and your budget.

What They Actually Do (Without the Tech Talk)

Let’s break it down.

Generative AI: Think of it like a never-tired writer with decent taste and zero complaints.

What can it whip up?

• Blog posts
  
• Product descriptions
  
• Ad copy
  
• Social media captions
  
• Even your Monday newsletter (before you finish your coffee)
  

It’s the digital version of, “I got this.”
You give it a prompt. It gives you content. No drama.

Conversational AI: This one’s like your most patient team member.

What can it handle?

• Customer questions (even the 50th “Where’s my order?”)
  
• Returns, reschedules, and refunds
  
• Website navigation help
  
• Appointment bookings
  
• Sales support in real-time
  

Always on. Never says “hold please.”

So which one should you use?

Depends on the task:

• Need content? Go Generative.
  
• Need conversations? Pick Conversational.
  

Both save time.
Both boost productivity.
Just don’t mix them up. It’s like asking your writer to answer phones. Doesn’t go well.

Setup Costs and Subscriptions: What You’ll Actually Pay

Let’s keep it real.
AI isn’t free, but it also doesn’t have to break the bank.

Generative AI: Affordable. But not totally hands-free.

Here’s what to expect:

• Most tools start with free trials
  
• Paid plans usually fall between $20–$100/month per user
  
• Great for writing… but it still needs a human eye
  
• You’ll spend time crafting prompts, editing tone, fixing odd phrasing
  

Kind of like hiring an intern with talent, you’ll need to guide it a bit.

Conversational AI: More powerful, more prep.

Costs look a little different here:

• Some charge per conversation
  
• Others use tiered plans based on usage or user seats
  
• Setup’s trickier, you’ll need to train it on your FAQs and brand voice
  
• Expect extra charges for fancy stuff like multilingual support or deep app integrations
  

It’s a heavier lift upfront.
But once it’s humming? It can scale like magic.

So… what should you choose?

Depends on your situation:

• Solo or small team? Generative AI gets you quick wins with less setup.
  
• Growing fast or buried in support tickets? Conversational AI for business support may save you more in the long run.
  

The good thing is that you don’t have to pick just one. Start where the pressure is. Let AI chip away at the time-wasters.

Match the AI to the Right Goal (So You Don’t Waste Money)

Want to save time and cash?
Don’t use the wrong AI for the job.

It’s like painting a wall with a spoon. Sure, it technically works, but why?

Use Generative AI when you need to create stuff.

Think:

• Blog posts on tight deadlines
  
• Cold emails that sound human
  
• Product descriptions that don’t all start the same
  
• Social captions that aren’t a total snoozefest
  

Perfect for marketers, copywriters, founders wearing too many hats. Interestingly, Generative AI chat tools can cut writing time in half.

Use Conversational AI when you need to guide or help.

Think:

• Answering FAQs at 3 a.m.
  
• Walking visitors through your site
  
• Helping customers find the “buy” button
  
• Following up when someone bails at checkout
  

Conversational AI for ecommerce can turn abandoned carts into orders.

Still unsure? Start with this:

• Need words? → Generative AI
  
• Need support? → Conversational AI
  

Pick the tool that fits the task.
Your budget and your team will thank you.

Hidden Costs You Shouldn’t Ignore

AI looks cheap on the surface.
But dig a little? There’s more under the hood.

Like those “$49 flights” that somehow cost $300 after bags and snacks.

Here’s what to watch out for:

1. Setup Time

Especially for conversational AI.

• You’ll need to train it on your FAQs
  
• Teach it your brand voice
  
• Double-check that it doesn’t say something… weird
  

Think of it like onboarding a new hire. Just faster. But not instant.

2. Integration Work

 AI tools rarely work straight out of the box.

• You might need help connecting them to your CRM
  
• Or syncing with Shopify, HubSpot, or Slack
  
• Some platforms charge extra for plug-ins and APIs
  

Tech help isn’t free, and it’s rarely quick.

3. Human Review

 Yes, AI writes fast. But it still makes mistakes.

• Typos
  
• Repeats
  
• Stuff that just doesn’t sound right
  

You’ll need someone to read, edit, and polish. Every time.

4. Usage Spikes

This one stings.

• Go over your monthly word count? Extra fee
  
• More chats than your plan allows? Surprise bill
  
• Add more team members? Cha-ching
  

Suddenly, your $49 tool feels like a hundred-dollar habit.

How to Measure Long-Term ROI (The Simple Way)

Let’s skip the spreadsheets.
ROI doesn’t have to feel like math class.

Here’s how to track the real wins—the ones you can actually feel.

1. Time Saved

This one shows up fast.

Ask yourself:

• Are you writing blog posts or emails faster?
  
• Is your team replying to support questions in minutes, not hours?
  
• Have boring tasks suddenly stopped clogging up mornings?
  

If your to-do list feels lighter?
That’s ROI.

2. Revenue Boost

Money talks. Especially over time.

Look at:

• Are more visitors buying?
  
• Are repeat customers coming back quicker?
  
• Did your average cart size get a little fatter?
  

Even small bumps add up.
Especially when AI runs in the background—quietly making things smoother.

3. Fewer Support Tickets

A good Conversational AI for customer engagement tool should reduce tickets, not add to the mess.

Check for:

• Fewer repetitive questions
  
• Shorter ticket queues
  
• Less time spent saying, “Did you try resetting your password?”
  

If your support team has time to breathe?
The tool’s working.

4. Better Content Output

Generative AI should feel like an extra pair of hands for your writers.

Watch for:

• More posts going out (without burnout)
  
• Higher quality drafts, faster
  
• Less time wasted staring at the blinking cursor
  

It’s not about more content.
It’s about more good content, with less stress.

Stick with What Works and Scale from There

Here’s something most companies overlook:
You don’t need to go all-in on every AI tool at once.

Seriously.
Trying to launch both Generative AI and Conversational AI on Day One?
That’s like trying to run a marathon with untied shoes.

Start simple. Start smart.

Pick the one thing that’s draining your team the most.

• Too many blog drafts clogging the pipeline? Go Generative.
  
• Support team drowning in repeat questions? That’s a job for Conversational AI.
  

Then? Test. Measure. Be honest.

Track what matters:

• Did it cut down on manual work?
  
• Are support replies faster?
  
• Did leads start coming in without more hustle?
  
• Is your sales team suddenly smiling more?
  

If the AI helps?
Keep it.

If it doesn’t?
Toss it.

Only scale what earns its spot.

Because smart AI should feel like:

• An extra set of hands
  
• A shortcut without shortcuts
  
• A tool that actually makes your job easier
  

And when it delivers those wins?

That’s when AI earns its keep.
And the ROI? Becomes a no-brainer.

Wrapping Up

Choosing the right AI isn’t about buzzwords. It’s about value.

Think of it like this:
You wouldn’t hire a designer to answer your phones. Or a support rep to write your website copy.

AI’s the same.

Let Generative AI help you say the right things.
Let Conversational AI help you say them at the right time.

And when done right?
Both can make your business feel smarter, faster… and more human.

For more business-friendly insights on AI, content, and customer experience, served simple, not stuffy, subscribe to our newsletter.

FAQs